CDF Persuades California Supreme Court to Throw Out Class Action Trial Plan And Judgment And Decertify The Class

Our client, a national bank, prevailed in the California Supreme Court following a first-of-its kind class action trial and multiple appeals.  CDF defended the bank against a class action alleging misclassification of exempt loan officers who were engaged in selling loans to small businesses.  The primary dispute at trial was the applicability of the California outside salesperson exemption to each employee in the class.  After aggressively defending the client against these claims for more than a decade, including a months-long class action trial premised on an unprecedented "representative" trial methodology that involved statistical terminology but ignored relevant legal and statistical principles, CDF appealed both the trial plan and class judgment, resulting in a reversal and an order decertifying the class from the Court of Appeal.  The plaintiffs petitioned the California Supreme Court for review, and CDF went on to successfully defend the client before the California Supreme Court.  The California Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeal's judgment in its entirety, resulting in a total victory for the bank - with the trial court judgment reversed and the class decertified.


California Supreme Court; California Court of Appeal, First District, Division 1; Alameda County Superior Court


Timothy M. Freudenberger
Kent J. Sprinkle
Alison L. Tsao

Related Industries

  • Financial Services

Related Case Studies

CDF Scores Decertification of Class After Strategic Removal And...

Business Fraud Claims Against Mortgage Company Rejected by Judge

Dismissal of Fraud and RICO Claims Leads to Favorable...

Gender Discrimination Case Against National Mortgage Lender Defeated in...

Employee Discharged for Misconduct Claiming Defamation Defeated At Trial

Financial Institution Reduces Threat of “Bet the Company” Litigation...

Jury Trial Delivers Defense Victory for a Major National...

Compliance Audit of Acquisition Target Reveals Critical Liability Info

Gender Discrimination Claims by Executive Defeated by Defense Verdict...

Double Defeat of Overtime Misclassification Class Certification

Carothers DiSante & Freudenberger LLP © 2018

Why CDFWhat We DoAttorneysCase StudiesNews & EventsOfficesAttorney AdvertisingDisclaimer