Trial Court Enters Complete Defense Verdict for Employer On Trial De Novo Appeal From Labor Commissioner Hearing

A former employee of an international electronic components company filed an appeal of a trial de novo to the Orange County Superior Court of his unsuccessful claim with the Labor Commissioner, alleging that his employer failed to reimburse him for business expenses incurred through the majority of his employment.   With the guidance of San Francisco partner Alison Tsao, Orange County associate Shirin Forootan's conducted a withering cross-examination of the Plaintiff, establishing that Plaintiff failed to timely submit his reimbursement requests while he was employed and did not attach any verifying documentation until the day of his hearing before the Labor Commissioner.  Ms. Forootan persuaded the trial court to grant the employer’s motion for judgment without the employer needing to put on its defense case, resulting in a complete victory for the employer.


Superior Court of California, County of Orange


Alison L. Tsao

Related Industries

  • Manufacturing

Related Case Studies

Class Action Proceedings Dismissed By The Los Angeles County...

Age and Disability Discrimination Claims Dismissed on Summary Judgment

Summary Judgment Dismissal in Gender Discrimination Claim Upheld on...

Manufacturer Wins Dismissal with Statute of Limitations Argument

Disability Discrimination Claim Settles After DFEH Sees CDF’s Summary...

CDF Turns Around Unfavorable Arbitration Award Restricting Manufacturer

EEOC Charge Defeated in Alleged National Origin Discrimination by...

Wage and Hour Class Action Against Medical Co. Settled...

Verdict Supports Aerospace Manufacturer’s Exempt Classification of Engineer

Consumer Products Company Needed H-1B Visa for Post Doctoral...

Carothers DiSante & Freudenberger LLP © 2018

Why CDFWhat We DoAttorneysCase StudiesNews & EventsOfficesAttorney AdvertisingDisclaimer